Ateh Jewel, Marie Claire's beauty columnist, talks about the Candice Brathwaite and Rochelle Humes docu debacle and why colourism - the preferential treatment of lighter-skinned individuals compared with darker-skinned Black people - must finally be acknowledged and action taken
When Candice Brathwaite took to Instagram on Saturday to state she was 'gutted' to discover she'd no longer be fronting a documentary on Black women and maternity mortality rates, days after she revealed she lost out on a job to lighter-skinned black woman 'more than once in the last six months'. A social media storm was unleashed. Colourism was making the headlines.
The Candice Braithwaite/Rochelle Humes social media documentary debacle has shone a light and opened up discussions about colourism and also how many black creatives are pitted against each other for the few crumbs from the table of power and access which are thrown our way.
A clearly very disappointed Candice, the best-selling author of I Am Not Your Baby Mother, has been campaigning for years about the high death rate of black women during pregnancy and childbirth in the UK. After thousands of messages of support and outraged indignation flooded Twitter and Instagram, the influencer and TV presenter later posted on her account clarifying rumours that the role she was talking about was taken from her by This Morning's Rochelle Humes. Stating she was 'never in the running' to host the show as both her and Rochelle were working on two different programmes.
But let me make it clear, I want to give a shout out and send lots of #blackgirlmagic support and love to both Candice and Rochelle over this.
Colourism and me - why we still have a long way to go
Over the past 20 years I have been passed over, I’ve had jobs signed off only to see them taken away and given to someone else, and the only way I found out was when I received an invitation and saw my name wasn’t on it. I’ve been told no one wanted to publish my books even though they loved the concepts because Funmi Fetto's Palette was being published. I argued that’s like saying you can only publish one thriller a year because you heard another thriller was being written (I was met by silence).
We have all been presented with the option by old gatekeepers that there is only space for one black voice at a time. It stings, it’s painful, it’s hurtful and it’s gaslighting bullshit. I’ve been watching The Hunger Games and there’s a line which rings true.. 'Remember who the real enemy is'. In this case the enemy is prejudice and a lack of diverse producers and gatekeepers signing off on more programming, making more space for more stories and conversations such as why black mothers have the highest childbirth mortality rates.
I remember when it was the Naomi Campbell v Tyra Banks days - when there could only be one black supermodel. Family members of mine were modelling in the 90s and they were told by agencies, 'sorry we already have one black model on our books'. Can you imagine them saying sorry we already have one blonde model, byeeeee'? No. I don't think so.
A couple of years ago I was told Candice was taking my space. She was my competition as if there is only room for one dark-skinned female voice talking about the things we talk about. Bullshit. No. I don’t accept that. Candice winning means I win. It means my daughters win. We all win and are enriched for having her unique voice.
But this is what we're dealing with now. It’s time to make some new doors to walk through so a situation where two powerful, fabulous queens - Candice and Rochelle - aren’t made to feel like this for just doing their art, wanting to tell stories and shining a light on a topic, which needs huge attention and action. Enough.
Colourism and my afro hair
All this discussion over colourism - the skin tone prejudice leads me on to another aspect of it: afro hair and my defining childhood experiences. Growing up, my curls were described as difficult, rebellious and unprofessional. When my daughters were 3 years old, a lady spotted us on the street and told me how beautiful my girls were but that my daughter with lighter skin, looser 3B curls and lighter skin was more beautiful. I informed her that both my daughters were beautiful and swiftly exited. My daughter who is darker with a thicker more defined 4A curl, turned to me and said, “Mama, did that woman think my sister was more beautiful than me because she has peach skin and blue eyes”. I told her the truth, “yes she does think those things, but she is wrong”. That day, my daughters learnt, aged 3, first hand what colourism - the discrimination of people with darker brown skin and the preference for people with more European features - really means in daily life.
For anyone who doesn't know, hair is graded by texture within the industry. Starting off at grade 1, is poker straight hair, with a soft wave referred to as grade 2B or 2C. After this are the 3A-C ringlets and curls similar to that of my lighter skinned daughter, and often seen on those of mixed or Irish heritage. Those with darker skin tend to have tight curls referred to as 4A or 4B curls, with my own tight coil curls being known as 4C.
As a dark skinned, coily haired, juicy, curvy half Nigerian/ Trinidadian woman, my body, skin tone and hair are rarely seen in advertising or aligned with power and luxury. Growing up my hair was described as difficult, rebellious, bush, hard to handle, messy and unprofessional. It hurt and damaged my self esteem and soul.
No one looked like me in boardrooms or as the leading lady in movies. I had the hair of maids and women on the verge of a nervous breakdown. If Julia Roberts with all her curls and charisma couldn’t land her man in ‘My Best Friend’s Wedding’ when pitted against Cameran Diaz’s wide eyed blonde straight haired ingenue - what chance did I have?
Equality, talking about colourism and curls and coils is something I have fought for throughout my 20 year beauty career. Twenty years ago, I had to beg to put a deep conditioner for curls into my copy for magazines and now things seem to be finally changing.
My 4C coils are often seen as the bottom of the curl world. I spent decades torturing and fighting my natural hair texture, so I could advance in my career in the beauty world and be seen and aligned with power. The techniques, tools and ingredients used to nourish and turn up the volume for juicy coils and curls were stolen along with slavery. The invisible poisonous gas of racism works by making you believe you’re less than, for being your most authentic self. Having “good hair” has meant in the past having soft, loose curls, which blows in the wind instead of growing straight up against gravity like my coils.
It was only after I became a mother to my now 9 year old mixed heritage twin daughters -my husband looks like a Viking, a 6’2 Blonde with blue eyes - that I decided I had to break my own cycle of hair straightening. From the age of 8 to 37, I was estranged from my naturally tightly coiled hair. My Trinidadian mother had smoother and looser curl texture to me. She couldn’t take the regular screams and tears over broken comb teeth and hours of frustrated detangling. So at 8, she chemically relaxed my hair for the first time. For the next 30 years I developed a love affair with “creamy crack” or hair straightening.
The visualisation of black women we see around us in the light skinned black models with loose curls akin to a “black barbie”, is laughable and dangerous.
Loving the hair that grows out of your head is about identity and self worth. I have just been appointed to the advisory board for the British Beauty Council, which is so important for younger generations watching me - I want to say your skin and coils is boardroom ready. In my role, I will be fighting for it to be mandatory for all hair stylists to learn how to cut and care for textured hair in the NVQ. At the moment it’s not and thousands of hair stylists are leaving higher education, with no idea how to look after my hair - why?
Not all hair is the same. Cutting curls and coils and learning how to make them pop is a specialised skill set. Only salons like Headmasters and Aveda are providing their own education. Charlotte Mensah, Subrina Kidd @subrinakidd and Paulette Blake @blake_paulette are also black stylists and stand outs for coils and curl excellence. Since BLM and Covid-19, the world has changed and people are now opening their eyes to the colourism, double standards, micro aggressions and racism, which has always been there. This is not a moment, but a movement and I look forward to a new beauty world, which recognises the beauty within all of us.
*To join Ateh's fight to promote diversity within the beauty industry, sign the petition to include textured hair education in the hairdressing NVQ*
Ateh's go-to products for textured hair:
Flexible Curl Activator and Moisturiser, Revlon Professional, £12.30
Helps to protect the natural volume of your curl and preserves colour
Dry Remedy Moisturizing Shampoo, Aveda, £24 for 250ml
The foundation of healthy curls and coils is a great shampoo to add hydration. I love this one by Aveda for my 4C coils. It’s softening with Buriti and Olive oil and isn’t full of synthetic fragrances which leaves my scalp itchy.
Medium Paddle Brush, Charlotte Mensah, £22
Multi Award Winning Afro Hairdresser of the Year Winner, has developed this amazing paddle brush, the air cushioned head protects the scalp and is great at detangling my thick coils and the girls’ curls.
Avocado Kokum Curl Defining Smoothie, Trepadora £21 for 200ml
This weightless leave in formula is great for creating definition in the girls hair. I like to apply it when their hair is wet after bath time and do what I call “bedtime plaits” to lock in moisturise and prevent their curls from becoming matted and tangled.
Shea Moisture Manuka Honey & Mafura Oil Conditioner, Superdrug, £12.99
I use this conditioner or a leave in, as it’s certified organic Shea Butter, Mafura and Baobab leaves hair feeling soft and supple.
*Ateh Jewel's new book Coils & Curls: The Ultimate Guide to Loving your Hair is out now - check out @atehjewel on Instagram for more details*
Marie Claire Newsletter
Celebrity news, beauty, fashion advice, and fascinating features, delivered straight to your inbox!
Dr Ateh Jewel is a multi-award-winning beauty journalist, influencer, broadcaster and diversity advocate. She's a regular presenter on this morning and social commentator on Good Morning Britain and CNN. She has been in the industry for 20 years specialising in beauty, social commentary and campaigning for more diversity in the Beauty industry. Ateh is launching her own beauty range Ateh Jewel Beauty in 2023. Please follow her @atehjewel on Instagram.
Plus size clothing brands to shop now and love forever
Here's what to add to your shopping list for 2024
By Penny Goldstone
Why Prince William has had to overcome a so-called 'allergy' to connect with royal fans
He had to move with the times
By Iris Goldsztajn
Leo Woodall on the 'horrible experience' of filming this key One Day scene
By Jadie Troy-Pryde
Why it's time we changed the narrative around black success
In the wake of England players Marcus Rashford, Jadon Sancho and Bukayo Saka being targeted with racial abuse, we need to rewrite the narrative around black success and failure says Charlotte Greene, co-founder of Black Owned eXcellence network, The B.O.X.
By Charlotte Greene
‘If you’re using the #NotAllMen hashtag, you’re part of the problem’
By Jenny Proudfoot
Munroe Bergdorf: 'Time's up on social media abuse'
Activist Munroe Bergdorf on why 2021 must be the year of lasting, impactful change online
By Sophie Goddard
Dr Shola Mos-Shogbamimu: 'We can’t talk about the dehumanisation of Black women without talking about colourism'
In the wake of the Candice Braithwaite and Rochelle Humes controversy, we hear from activist, attorney and author of This is Why I Resist, Dr Shola Mos-Shogbamimu – who says we must not pit Black women against each other, but instead hold our TV Networks to account.
By Marie Claire
'We cannot ignore the white privilege on display at last night's Capitol Hill riot'
By Jenny Proudfoot
US Election 2020 - An Insider Tells All: ‘There’s no coming back from this, is there’
Days before the most consequential election ever, Becca Andrews, a journalist at US news site Mother Jones, reveals what it's like living in Trump’s America and why, along with tens of millions, she’s holding her breath expecting the worst
By Marie Claire
Instagram turns 10: but is it breaking us or making us more human?
Happy birthday Instagram! A simple photo-sharing app was born on 6 October 2010 and changed the world for better or worse. Now home to more than a billion active users, author Daisy Buchanan examines her complicated relationship with it
By Maria Coole
'Why do we still have a problem with race?' asks anti-racism activist Layla F Saad
How do you become a better anti-racist ally in 2020? For starters, recognise that if you're white and privileged, you're probably helping uphold an oppressive system. On Black History Month, we're shining a spotlight on what Layla. F Saad, author of Me and White Supremacy, has to say about shutting down racism
By Marie Claire