There are countless five-star mascaras on the market, but as someone with very oily eyelids and eyes that constantly water, very few pass my scrupulous tests. For the average mascara wearer, I would say that high street and high end formulas can be equally as effective at creating lift, volume, and thickness, but the features I look for tend to come at steeper price points.
I need a mascara that won't smudge onto or under my lids, flake off, or run down my cheeks with a little bit of moisture. I have long believed that the best mascaras for me are those with 'tubing' properties that coat each lash and don't move at all throughout the day, but they aren't so easy to come by if you're shopping on the high street.
It was only after finding out that Rimmel London's new Thrill Seeker Extreme mascara is smudge-proof, flake-free, and clump-free that I considered trying out a new type of formula—and I'm so glad that I did.
Before vs after using Rimmel Thrill Seeker Extreme Mascara
I'm always nervous about testing a new mascara for fear of looking in the mirror after a few hours to see black smudges everywhere, so I first used Thrill Seeker with cautious optimism. When applying, I liked that the formula was neither too thick nor too watery, so I didn't have to worry about making a mess before I even left the house.
But I really fell in love after a trip to the bathroom half way through my work day, when I was shocked to see that the mascara hadn't gone anywhere. This was something I had only ever properly experienced with my £32 designer mascara, so I definitely didn't expect it from a drugstore product that's more than half the price.
Thrill Seeker not only boasts 24 hour wear, but also has a tapered fibre brush is designed to grab and coat each lash for instant impact and volume. The buildable formula means it can also be used for a more natural look if that's your preference on lighter makeup days.
The true black colour gives noticeable definition, and I found that I only needed a couple of quick swipes to get good payoff. It's also ophthalmologist tested, so it's safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers—good news for me and my constantly streaming eyes.
After a lengthy day in the office as well as sweaty periods spent on the tube and running around London, I'm pleased to report my lashes were still fully in tact when it came time to take my makeup off.
If you're on the hunt for an affordable, everyday mascara that will stay put all day long, Thrill Seeker Extreme is one of the best drugstore mascaras I have tried in a very long time.
Celebrity news, beauty, fashion advice, and fascinating features, delivered straight to your inbox!
Amelia is Junior Shopping Editor at Marie Claire UK. With a keen eye for lifestyle trends and a focus on quality over quantity, she is very clued up on the best products and brands on the market. She previously worked as a Senior Writer for woman&home, covering everything from product reviews and nail art trends to reporting on fashion weeks and the best-dressed celebrities at red carpet events.
-
The Pre-Black Friday Deals on the Beauty Heroes That Were Already On Your WishlistWe’ve analysed search trends and retailer data to identify this year’s most-wanted beauty gifts—and found the best Black Friday deals on each.
-
The Low-Cost Wellness Habits That Make the Biggest Difference, According to Top ExpertsThese are the habits you can’t afford to skip.
-
Julia Garner’s Faux Fur-Trim Puffer is the Answer to Staying Warm Without Compromising Fashion CredibilityLook no further for a masterclass in cold-weather dressing.
-
The Pre-Black Friday Deals on the Beauty Heroes That Were Already On Your WishlistWe’ve analysed search trends and retailer data to identify this year’s most-wanted beauty gifts—and found the best Black Friday deals on each.
-
The Beauty Digest: Lip Balms Are the New It-Bags, Diptyque Does Halloween & Bobbi Brown Does It AgainA Beauty Director’s weekly edit of the launches worth knowing, treatments worth trying and industry talking points you’ll want an opinion on.
-
Why Makeup Artists Are Embracing the Anti-Blush Movement—And How to Make It Look GoodMove over, blush blindness
-
Lisa Eldridge Says Oily Skin Can Still Have Glass-Like Glow—Here’s How She Gets the Balance RightThe make-up artist shares her expert tricks for balancing glow and shine.
-
The Beauty Digest: Nobel Prize-Winning Skincare, a Very Chic Body Brush and the Future of LED TherapyFrom Nobel Prize-winning skincare technology to a new generation of personalised LED therapy, these are the beauty discoveries worth knowing about this week.
-
The Beauty Digest: Cécred Comes to the UK, Romilly Wilde Returns & £22 Skincare Gets SeriousThis week’s biggest beauty news, launches and comebacks—plus the products genuinely worth having on your radar.
-
Clinique Just Turned Viral Black Honey Lipstick Into a Full Collection—I've Tried Them All, and I Have ThoughtsCan the Iconic 1970s berry hue work on eyes, cheeks, and nails?
-
Fenty Beauty Just Replaced Its Most Iconic Foundation—3 Editors Put Its “Flexible” Full Coverage to the Test50 new shades, flexible medium-to-full coverage and 12-hour wear—but does Fenty’s new Pro Filt’r live up to the original?