Has Simon Cowell made the biggest mistake of his career so far by sacking Mrs C from the panel?
Although Girls Aloud singer Cheryl was axed from the show back in May - when SiCo felt she was ‘uncomfortable’ on the panel - she still appears in the opening episode which will air on UK TV tonight on ITV2.
One review read: ‘In the premiere Cheryl just kind of disappears mid show, without much explanation, and suddenly Nicole Scherzinger of Pussycat Dolls is in her chair.’
It seems Simon Cowell’s doubts that the Americans wouldn't understand Cheryl couldn't have been more wrong as critics praised the Newcastle-born singer for her ‘fabulous Geordie accent!’
The US TV Guide magazine backed Cheryl’s corner, too, saying, ‘she was perfectly understandable. Well-spoken and charming, too. Her replacement Nicole Scherzinger’s robotic comments are grating by comparison.’
In fact, the general consensus from US critics was that the replacement of Nicole Scherzinger was a 'downgrade' from Cheryl.
The Chicago Tribune read, ‘Scherzinger doesn't come off as an obvious improvement’, while the LA Times wrote: ‘on a first impression, she [Cheryl] is much more interesting than Scherzinger.’
It seems Simon Cowell’s plans for an American take-over may have backfired, with some sources branding it ‘a bad call which could affect the success of the show long-term.'
And he was dealt another blow earlier this week, when Cheryl reportedly turned down his offer to become a judge on UK show Britain’s Got Talent. Oh dear...
Will you be watching Cheryl’s performance in tonight’s X Factor USA? We want to hear YOUR thoughts on if she is a worthy judge. Let us know in the comments box below…
Marie Claire Newsletter
Celebrity news, beauty, fashion advice, and fascinating features, delivered straight to your inbox!
Be the star gift giver this Christmas with a personalised piece of jewellery to make loved ones smile
If your list of loved ones is long and you’re stumped for ideas, there’s one gift that always keeps on giving – and that’s the perfect piece of jewellery.
By Anna-Louise Dearden
How to get tickets to see Eurovision 2024 live
Scandinavia is calling!
By Lauren Hughes
Emily Ratajkowski faces backlash for 'fatphobic' and 'tone deaf' photoshoot
People are calling for the model to apologise for the image
By Iris Goldsztajn