Who wore it best? Drew Vs. Katherine

Katherine Jenkins looks the best, her lovely figure suits the style, sorry Drew Barrymore it does nothing for you, looks far too big.
Comment by Cynthia Davies on November 04 12:50

Well...we have the same scenario as Mariah and Kate...
Katherine looks great as it is very tight and fitted for a sexy look and Drew seems to have one size too big or something.shame but in all honesty..its not really Drews thing I dont think....needed to be smaller...its all too flat and not her and the shoes are not good.
She normally looks great..looks a bit too Gynee Palt look...not her.
Comment by anon on November 04 12:57

I agree with Sarah and Vivienne - Drew B looks as if she's wearing a size too big - she's definitely not filling the dress in the right place!
Comment by Sian on November 04 13:25

I think Katherine wins it too, the dress just fits her better, and i really like her metallic shoes and bag.
Comment by Josie on November 04 13:26

Drew Barrymore just looks fantastic, so glamorous and sophisticated, whereas on Katherine Jenkins it's a bit too Footballer's wives.......
Comment by Joanne on November 04 13:31

Katherine! x
Comment by Kate on November 04 13:32

Katherine wins hands down!
Comment by James on November 04 14:28

Much better on Katherine by a mile. Quite shapeless and a little boring on Drew.
Comment by Gerry on November 04 14:32

Katherine wears dresses that both suit her and fit her - I have yet to see her in one that does neither!
Comment by Barry Barney on November 04 14:34

I don't think the dress looks great on either of them. It's too long. If I had to say I'd go with Drew.
Comment by Athina Clarke on November 04 15:46

Katherine, no question! Much curvier, plus her skin tone compliments the colour of the dress and her make up is spot-on. I actually quite fancy Drew, but her skin tone and make up are way off for that dress. I may be a straight guy with no fashion sense of my own, but I know when a woman looks good ;-)
Comment by Tom on November 04 15:49

Katherine looks weird as if she's holding her breathe and her stomach in.
Comment by Lynsie on November 04 16:12

Katherine wore it best without doubt - she has a better figure and looks amazing.
It doesn't look like the same dress on Drew, plus I am not sure about red lipstick with it..
Comment by juliemforum on November 04 16:16

Katherine looks elegant and classy while Drew doesn't seem to fit the dress well at all!
Comment by Jim on November 04 16:30

drew!!!! way more original!!
Comment by lemon on November 04 16:46

Katherine Jenkins looks great - dress fits her figure so well.No competition with the ill-fitting dress Drew is wearing.
Comment by kathy on November 04 16:53

Katherine looks fabulous, as usual, whereas Drew looks as though she is desperately pinning it to her body with her elbows in order to prevent it falling down, 'cos she's not got enough 'up top 'to hold it up!
Comment by jayprime on November 04 16:56

Katherine by a mile!
Comment by Tegwen on November 04 22:15

Sorry to say it, but Katherine looks like a Hollyoaks actress at the soap awards - all shiny tight material, a horrid (and boring) hairstyle, and fake tan. And whats with the over posing and uncomfortable smile? she looks like shes trying too hard. Drew on the other hand, looks elegant and chic. The dress hangs off her beautifully and looks beautiful against her fair skin. love.
Comment by Holly on November 05 06:29

Katherine looks the best by far. What a figure! It looks a different dress entirely on Drew. However, make-up wise Drew nails it.
Comment by Lucy on November 05 09:18

For me, these pictures demonstrate the difference between wearing something because it looks right and wearing something because it's fashionable. Drew looks awkward, doesn't suit the dress, and it looks the wrong size. On Katherine it looks perfect, she is sleek, elegant and her natural shape is accentuated without it looking tarty. Drew's lipstick choice is wrong to me and her shoes look clumsy. I prefer Katherine's look more and I love those shoes - I want some !! Katherine wins this one easily!
Comment by Nick on November 05 22:27

I can't decide!
I love the way Drew accessorized and it fits her style perfectly, but it almost makes her look a bit matronly.
And Katherine looks stunning,and the dress shows off her curves wonderously, but I do not like that particular hair do with that dress.
Comment by jessica on November 07 19:52

Katherine wears it beautifully - she looks stunning. I don't think it fits Drew quite as well :(
Comment by Katie on November 14 20:12