Who wore it best? Cheryl Cole Vs. Emma Bunton

I cant believe people think it looks better on cheryl! Shes the size of a 9 year old child.
Its Emma all the way.
Comment by Annette on July 16 13:09

Really??
Cheryl all day long :)

Comment by Amz on July 16 13:15

Cheryl ofcourse- need you even ask this question!!
Comment by maddy on July 16 13:17

It has to be Emma. She looks like a woman! Cheryl is verging on the 'micro' ridiculous - she's starting to look like my daughters Barbie.
Comment by Eva on July 16 13:20

they both look awful, it's a terrible skirt.
sick of the sight of both of them !!
Comment by Jayne on July 16 13:21

Emma, definitley. That shirt Cheryl is wearing is looks like cheap office wear.
Comment by Holly on July 16 13:23

Emma, Cheryl just looks like a barbie.
:)
Comment by Rachael on July 16 13:27

Very definitely Cheryl, she could wear a black bin liner and still look fabulous and she has a terrific personality
Comment by maggie on July 16 13:29

Emma looks like a woman - Cheryl looks like a twiglet in a skirt
Comment by Linda Dalton on July 16 13:34

Emma,she has more shape instead of the straight up and down of Cheryl.
Comment by Jill on July 16 13:35

Definately Cheryl no contest x
Comment by Kim on July 16 13:44

Emma Bunton looks better, definitely. She's got the curves for it
Comment by Emm on July 16 13:49

Rule number one - show off your cleavage or your pins..not at the same time. Cheryl wins.
Comment by Tessa on July 16 14:07

As much as I like Cheryl, on this occasion I'd go for Emma, although after taking a second look I've decided I don't really like the skirt anyway!
Comment by Helen C on July 16 14:30

Emma definately. Cheryl is too thin, the skirt looks really flattering on emma but on cheryl it draws attention to how tiny shes become. I also like the black best, the white is a bit too barbie doll costume.
Comment by Laura on July 16 15:20

Cheryl by far!!! :D
Comment by Christiana on July 16 16:08

CHERYLL! how can you even question that! :D
Comment by cherylcolefannn! on July 16 16:26

Cheryl definately. She makes the mini skirt look much lighter and fresher. As for Emma; showing your bra is so not a good look.
Comment by Kioni-Dream on July 16 16:26

cheryl looks like a tart in it, emma more sophisticated, or just like a lady.
Comment by nick on July 16 16:56

Emma definitely. Cheryl doesn't even choose the clothes herself. Also, she just looks unnaturally skinny!
Comment by S. on July 16 17:43

emma because she's more shapely
Comment by lu on July 16 18:21

Emma looks better
Comment by Marllon on July 16 18:24

It's gotta be Cheryl! :D totally chezzalicious! :P xxx
Comment by Liz on July 16 20:20

Emma. Cheryl is lovely looking but Emma adds more to the skirt in terms of being fuller; she wears the shape better.
Comment by xxbeccasxx on July 16 21:10

While I admire Cheryl's straightforward attitude, how can you be holding her up as a style icon when she has wasted herself away to look like a 12 year-old....and no, before anyone says it, I'm not fat. I just think that people need to have a wake up call about what is healthy and what isn't. If one of your friends lost as much weight as Cheryl, wouldn't you be worried too.
Comment by AD on July 16 22:24

Emma!! of course
Comment by Natalia on July 17 01:21

Cheryl ofcourse !!!!!!!!!!!
Comment by Ash on July 17 08:36

i think emma buton look so nice
Comment by jennifer on July 17 08:39

Cheryl looks really cheap,How can she be considered sexy, She has no curves.lol. Emmas looks way hotter
Comment by Mark on July 17 11:02

Emma definately Cheryl just looks ill!
Comment by Teresa on July 17 11:53

Cheryl's one is too short.
Emma is more elegant
Comment by Daniele on July 17 14:37

Emma wore it best she had it on first! Emmas the best!!!!!!!!!
Comment by Julie on July 17 15:02

The gold Necklace Cheryl is wearing is amazing
its from Ring Leader by Katie Rowland!
:D

Comment by Jean on July 17 15:22

How predictable. the skinny one is the most preferred...
Comment by Chaz on July 18 14:17

I think both look good, but i'd have to give this one to cheryl, though usually i don't like her style, i think she paired it with a better top than emma did on this occasion.
Comment by Jenn on July 18 15:26

How can you really say emma cheryl is millions times better looking and a true style icon!! My word people these days eh?
Comment by Rob on July 18 23:40

Emma looks gorgeous and has a much healthier frame than Cheryl to wear the skirt on :)
Comment by Jess on July 19 10:59

before I read anyone else's comments my first thought on seeing Cheryl was 'Barbie'. Emma has a lovely fuller figure and is more womanly. Most men I know prefer a few curves, and I think it's a shame to be comparing two very different figures.
Comment by cathy on July 19 12:39

Emma definitely, it shows just how ridiculously tiny Cheryl is so she ends up looking more like a little girl dressed up!
Comment by Nina on July 20 11:04

Definately Emma Bunton! Cheryl is too skinny and looks cheap!
Comment by Hassan on July 21 21:31

Is Emma going bald?! Her hairline looks like it's receding badly, and her hair looks lank and thin. And why does she always insist on revealing her sun-damaged, spaniel-ear boobs? Has someone told her it's sexy?

I'm not a fan of either of them, but Cheryl wears it better by a country mile.
Comment by Tally on July 22 12:01

Cheryl, no doubt.
Comment by Amy on August 14 11:17

Emma Bunton looks much hotter. she has a sexy curvy body that Cheryl can't match at all
Comment by kaudaj on December 18 18:07

i think that cheryl wore it the beautiful
Comment by andrew hutton on July 28 19:27

Emma wins an easy fight here. she's curvier and sexier than Cheryl and in a catfight Emma has more Girl Power. Emma wins all the way!
Comment by joan on September 04 07:40

They both look great in the bow-front - Emma's better looking - but Cheryl got the look!
Comment by yourenergysurvey@yahoo.com on March 21 18:56