CELEBRITY STYLE SPY: See all the latest celeb photos

Who wore it best? Cheryl vs. Dannii

By Lucy Hutchings on Tuesday 14 July 2009

Print
Share
Comment

Cheryl Cole - Celebrity News - Marie Claire

As X Factor's reigning style queens, it's no surprise that judges Dannii Minogue and Cheryl Cole are the subject of many a fashion face-off, but yesterday in Glasgow the ladies showed they share a certain common style obsession: YSL's Tribute pumps.

Arriving for the latest round of auditions, both pitched up with their toes clad in the gravity defying six-inch stilettos – loved by the likes of Victoria Beckham, Kate Moss, Jennifer Lopez and Eva Longoria, to name merely a few.

And though their tootsies may have been matching, sartorially the well-heeled pair couldn't have styled their statement shoes more differently.

Keeping thing casual, Cheryl donned white skinny jeans, and a monochrome print vest. Those much-envied locks were characteristically loose and wavy, and she added a pop of colour with a slick of raspberry lipstick.

In comparison, Dannii looked uber-polished in an elegant Donna Karan tailored tuxedo dress, belted with a patent waist-cincher, and wearing her new bob wavy and side-swept.

Cheryl Cole & Dannii Minogue - Celebrity News - Marie Claire

The duo may have been identical from the ankle-down, but with very different ensembles above, the question is, who wore it best? It's your turn to take the judges seat - let us know your verdict in the comments box below.

SEE CHERYL'S STYLE HIGHS AND LOWS HERE

Tuesday 14 July 2009

Have your say ...

Add your own comment

Dannii by far wins this one!
Dannii looks fab and classy whereas Cheryl looks a bit too girl-on-the-street.
Comment by Elle on July 14 11:03

CHERYL! all the way :)
Comment by Emma on July 14 11:37

dannii
Comment by kiki on July 14 12:09

Dannii is just classic she wins hands down all the way ....... xx
Comment by Elias on July 14 12:33

Has to be Dannii here. So chic
Comment by Kelly on July 14 12:37

Danni looks fresher, brighter, classier and more unique. Cheryl needs a style overhaul. They could wear Primark for all we care, its' more of the same ole same look.
Comment by Cats on July 14 12:37

Dannii - Cheryl looks a bit chav here
Comment by LB on July 14 12:38

Danni. No doubt about it..
Comment by m on July 14 12:39

Dannii definitely!
Comment by Cat on July 14 12:46

Dannii looks amazing in that Donna Karan tuxedo dress!
Comment by Alex on July 14 12:47

CHERYL for sure :D
Comment by Christiana on July 14 12:48

Dannii
Comment by Lucy B on July 14 12:48

Cheryl is far too skinny! Not a good role model for young girls.
Danni looks like a real woman and is getting classier every time.

Comment by Joanne on July 14 12:52

They are both walking adverts for Gucci Group (McQueen top, YSL belt and shoes, Balenciaga bag).
How completely boring and blantant PR!
This is what happens when press offices send you freebies!
Comment by stylish on July 14 12:53

Dannii looks amazing! :D
Comment by Lydia on July 14 12:53

Danni, no question - classy, sassy, she's got it!
Comment by bpirockin on July 14 12:59

Defo Dannii! Cheryl looks likes she's gone back to her roots for style tips, not good
Comment by vic on July 14 13:02

Danni looks best
Comment by althea morgan on July 14 13:03

I love Cheryl, but this year without a shadow of a doubt, Dannii has put herself in a different league...she looks fab!
Comment by Sophia on July 14 13:08

Danii's outfit is boring, she could have at least spiced it up by wearing some more exciting shoes. Cheryl got the balance right.
Comment by ivy on July 14 13:25

Danni is super chic in Donna Karan- no contest
Comment by Violet Smith on July 14 13:43

Danni looks FABULOUS!! Her Iconic Donna dress is timess and efortless! BRAVO Danni
Comment by JC on July 14 13:59

Yup Danni defo walks this one away! :-)
Comment by Lulu on July 14 14:03

Dannii looks amazing in this outfit soooo much better than cheryl!! i love what they are both wearing but think that dannii definetly pulls off the sky high heels much better!!!!!
Comment by Amy on July 14 14:38

Dannii has really stepped up since her new hair cut. Sadly, Cheryl looks tarty as always!
Comment by Vicki on July 14 14:42

Dear Stylish,
I happened to be shopping at Donna Karan when Danni was. I saw her put her credit card down. I was impressed myself! She is a shopper! Ahh stars they're just like us : )
Comment by Marisa Lowe on July 14 15:22

Dannii by a clear mile.
Although I have to say the shoes are still hideous. Sorry.
Comment by Kioni-Dream on July 14 15:38

Definitely Dannii, Cheryl doesn't seem to have made an effort
Comment by Carole on July 14 16:21

Dannii wins, Cheryl looks trashy
Comment by Nikki on July 14 16:34

has 2 be cherylx
Comment by lucy on July 14 16:46

Love Cheryl but Dannii wins this Round!
Comment by Laura on July 14 16:52

Dannie - classy lady
Comment by Anna on July 14 16:56

Danni - she looks really elegant.
Comment by Sheelagh on July 14 18:22

Definitely Dannii!!! Very stylish
Comment by Vee on July 14 18:50

Dannii wins here
Comment by Steph on July 14 19:05

Cheryl, by a mile.
Comment by Margaret on July 14 19:11

Dannii looks the best by far - very stylish.
Comment by Jem on July 14 20:40

Dannii looks way classier
Comment by nikki on July 14 21:36

CHERYL!! come on people, danni minougue? are you actually serious! pahah!
Comment by LOVEFORTHECOLES! on July 15 07:29

Cheryl,
the heals are to much for dannii's lovelly dress!
Comment by sarah on July 15 08:06

Dannii Minogue by far. She has a classy dress sense and she has the most amazing eyes. She is very sexy, stylish and stunning.

Cheryl on the other hand just looks like an average person you see on the streets.
Comment by Diana on July 15 09:29

Dannii wins hands down - so chic
Comment by Champagnedoll on July 15 10:49

Dannii - the shoes are not my taste, but at least she makes them look more stylish than Walker's Ct.
Comment by d on July 15 13:40

Danni is the winner , classy
Comment by claire on July 15 14:41

Danni gets my vote, I want her dress!
Comment by Cli on July 15 21:33

Mini Minogue wins this round by far. She has really oozed style this season, and the short hair is a refreshing change.
Comment by Ryan on July 16 06:28

None of them look fab!
But danni looks a little better.
Comment by RABIA on July 16 08:47

Got to be Dannii she looks verry classy and smart where as cheryl just looks a bit plane

Dannii all the way i say xxxx
Comment by Nicola Price on July 16 12:26

CHERYL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Comment by Ellie on August 03 18:34

CHERYL! all the way she wins hands down
Comment by samantha on September 07 09:18

cheryl has to win 100%, however i must say that Dannii looks fantastic too!
Comment by nikki on November 14 14:16

i think cheryl and dannii are both realli pritty but cheryl wins this one im afraid...
Comment by emily on December 28 08:50

sorri buh cheryl wears it so much better as much as i like what dannii has on cheryl wins it by far... cheryl all the way
Comment by emily on January 31 21:25

dannii minogue is more sophisticated and she is older, has better teaste than cheryl and cheryl has a million stylists, dannii has - NONE.
Comment by kerr on May 01 12:04

Read all 54 comments