CELEBRITY STYLE SPY: See all the latest celeb photos

More Cameron Diaz

Who wore it best? Cameron Vs. Pippa

By Eleanor Young on Tuesday 3 May 2011

Print
Share
Comment

Pippa Middleton Cameron Diaz - Pippa Middleton - Cameron Diaz - Pippa Middleton dress - Alice Temperley - Dress - Marie Claire - Marie Claire UK

Pippa Middleton stole the show when she stepped out in a cream Alexander McQueen creation as Kate Middleton’s Maid of Honour at the Royal Wedding on Friday, but we couldn’t shake the feeling we’d seen it before. And we had! On Cameron Diaz, at Golden Globes in 2009.

The pair played style snap on two very different red carpets, but who do YOU think rocked the look best?

PIPPA MIDDLETON STYLE HISTORY

Hollywood royalty Miss Diaz gave the form-fitting McQueen gown it’s first public outing more than a year ago at the glittering Golden Globe Awards in 2009.

Cameron chose a red version of the slinky satin dress for her award appearance, accessorising her A-list outfit with towering Ferragamo peep-toes, a glittering gold Van Cleef and Arpel, and a sweep of sizzling red lipstick.

The star also accessorised with a cleverly matched umbrella on the rainy evening.

More than a year later, the fresh-faced and dazzling younger Middleton stepped out in the very same gown as she played Maid of Honour at the wedding of the century – the nuptials of William and Kate.

Pippa kept her winter white version perfectly sleek and simple, adding towering white Jimmy Choos, drop diamond and pearl earrings - reportedly designed by her mother – and Lily of the Valley flowers in her Richard Ward-tended tresses.

Designers at McQueen also added a tiny embellished edge to Miss Middleton’s glittering gown, finishing off with a line of slinky, silk covered buttons, running the length of her spine.

Two stylish fashionistas, one stunning slinky gown. But, we want to know who YOU think rocked the red carpet look best? Let us know in the comments box below.

SEE MORE STARS PLAYING STYLE SNAP HERE!

PIPPA MIDDLETON FASHION EVOLUTION

MORE CELEBRITY NEWS

More Cameron Diaz
More Pippa Middleton

Tuesday 3 May 2011

Have your say ...

Add your own comment

pippa middleton
Comment by zk on May 03 10:56

Pippa by a mile, or ten
Comment by rkem on May 03 12:51

Definitely Pippa.
Comment by Solapsis on May 03 12:56

I think Pippa wore it best! She is beautiful just like her now royal sister. x
Comment by Kate on May 03 12:58

They're two different dresses - very similar, but different. You can see across the waist that pippa's 'triangle goes up, whereas cameron's triangle goes downwards which means the fabric will hang differently. Also the detail on the sleeves is different and the chest line. I prefer Pippa from the front, but not the dress from the back.
Comment by lemmi on May 03 12:59

No contest Pippa looked stunning
Comment by Fiona on May 03 13:03

the dresses are similar but not the same the detailing on the front of the dresses is different(there is a v front on camerons)but def pippa
Comment by Geraldine King on May 03 13:09

definitely pippa
Comment by sroche on May 03 13:13

Pippa!!
Comment by Karin on May 03 13:19

Definitely Pippa! She looked classy.
Comment by Kate on May 03 13:31

no contest, Pippa
Comment by susan on May 03 13:33

Is Pippa a celebrate now?
Comment by Sophia on May 03 13:57

Pippa looks lovely in her dress and Cameron looks lovely in hers as other people have said already these dresses are not the same look at then again
Comment by nannyof9 on May 03 14:18

Pippa looked miles better
Comment by frankie on May 03 14:41

their is no compition pippa wins sorry diaz its just not your look!!!

Comment by roisin on May 03 15:40

Pippa - no contest she is simply stunning
Comment by claire on May 03 15:53

Pippa by far has the best dress and she is rocking that dress.

Comment by Rose on May 03 16:04

Pippa Looks way better
Comment by joe on May 03 16:14

Pippa looks miles better!! But as previously stated above, NOT the same dress. Totally different at the front.
Comment by Gill on May 03 16:19

You rock it Pippa
Comment by Naway on May 03 16:28

I totally agree with most No Contest, Pippa
Comment by Linda on May 03 16:29

Pippa definitley.
Comment by Kim on May 03 17:00

The dresses are NOT the same. Very similar but the under bust stitching makes each dress hang differently. Pippa deffo gets my vote. No contest
Comment by linda on May 03 18:57

definitely Pippa, no question about it.
Comment by Jackie on May 03 19:09

Definitely Pippa. Very Classy and very chic
Comment by shelagh green on May 03 19:14

pippa hands down, she is the best by a country mile....
Comment by courtney james locke on May 03 19:26

Pippa knocked spots off Cameron and is a natural beauty like her sister. She looked elegant, stunning, classy and absolutely gorgeous in that dress...very befitting for a maid of honour at a royal wedding
Comment by Gill on May 03 21:10

Pippa looked fabulous winner hands down!!!
Comment by Kathleen on May 03 21:14

pippa looked lovely in her dress so does cameron in hers, but though the dresses look alike they are not the same, i liked pippa dress better it had more detail to it.x
Comment by lemons on May 03 22:54

The dresses are very similar but there are subtle differences eg neckline, waist, colour!! Pippa's dress was how I'd imagined Kate's would be. Now that would have been stunningly different. Pippa definately stole the show, she looked sensational - which she was.
Comment by She0212 on May 03 22:59

Pippa's dress is much nicer and worn better. As before the dresses are not identical only similar in styling. Pippas dress hangs much better as Cameron's looks much too tight to me. Also some dodgy seamwork puckering the front. Perhaps due to the creasing the red dress just dosen't look as nice.
Comment by Rosie on May 03 23:13

Without a doubt Pippa is the clear winner on this one. She looked incredible!
Comment by Sophie on May 03 23:20

Pippa-1, Cameron-0 She's beautiful!!

Comment by Martin on May 03 23:28

Pippa. The dresses are similar but not the same. Prefer the "Pippa" version.
Comment by Meriel on May 03 23:50

Please...not even close! Take a better look or get new glasses!
Comment by Linda Ross on May 04 00:52

Pippa, with out a doubt.
Comment by Tracy Widhalm on May 04 01:48

Pippa of course!!!
Comment by Dee on May 04 03:37

Pippa, looks good in that dress!
Comment by elaine durham on May 04 06:05

Definately pippa xxx
Comment by Hareesh on May 04 07:23

OOOh - what a good style spot! I loved that dress on Cameron, and Pippa looked sensational at the wedding. I think they both win!
Comment by josie on May 04 10:47

Absolutely Pippa! She looked stunning and she has the perfect figure for that style of dress. Beautiful!
Comment by Amanda Powell on May 04 11:12

PIPPa all t he way but the dresses are diffrent. but still pippa x
Comment by nichole :P on May 04 11:52

Pippa obviously!!!she looks elegant and natural, Cam looks plastic,overly made up that red lippy is a no no too matchy and a big no to those shoes...
Comment by Andrea on May 04 12:58

Pippa of course!
Comment by Stephanie on May 04 13:15

Pippa - absolutely stunning
Comment by Christine Anderson on May 04 14:57

Pippa-a natural beauty...
Comment by Margaret Young on May 04 19:01

PIPPA WAS AMAZING , DRESS NOT THE SAME , SIMILAR BUT A LOT CLASSIER M WHAT A STUNNER ,
Comment by CAROL IRENE HAMER on May 04 19:29

Pippa definitely, but think you're a bit wide of the mark to say she stole the show. I think her sister was pretty stunning too!
Comment by Jane Marti on May 04 22:24

Pippa's version is much more elegant and she looked gorgeous.
Comment by isabella on May 05 13:16

Pippa looks so much more elegant!!!
Comment by B on May 09 11:47

I think it's the white colour that steals the show. The simplicity just goes away with the red!

Comment by Samreen on May 09 17:55

Read all 51 comments