The ankle diet was a joke. geez.
Comment by Dan on October 30 11:11

Think you need to go to humour school Dan... Joke! x
Comment by MB on October 30 11:22

OMG..... none !!! who wants to look like and easter egg.... gosh thats awful.. im sorry... they are both very slim girls.. trying to make themselves look larger ???? eeeerrr isnt this industry known for trying to make us look like a size 0 - 6 ...confused.... leave the egg buts BEHIND huns.....
Comment by Darcey on October 30 11:55

Ha ha!! love the easter egg comment. I couldn't agree more Darcey...
Comment by Josie on October 30 12:42

I'd hate to say, mainly because I think the dress is absolutely awful and it's areally hard call. It's just ridiculous. I can see what Dan means about an ankle diet, all a bit straight, but perhaps a little calf muscle might help instead! Both pairs of shes pretty forgettable too. Did I say, I don't like it??!!
Comment by Tricia on October 30 12:50

I think considering both girls have tons of money and hundreds of designers throwing their clothes at them to wear, WHY DID THEY CHOOSE THIS???????? It loooks like a lampshade from B & Q!!
Comment by Hayley on October 30 12:52

That is indeed a strange looking dress. But I'll still say Cheryl.
Comment by Kate on October 30 13:23

cheryl does have kankles...fat ankles lol...the dress is awful but both girls r gorgeous
Comment by geraldine on October 30 13:47

Hideous dress on both... like red frog spawn or some slop jelly...yuk
absolutely appalling.
Comment by anon on October 30 14:12

Said at the time that I thought the dress was horrendous, like a crinoline that has had the bottom cut off, don't like either of them unless they think that having bulbous hips is a new style!!!!!
Comment by Janet de Vries on October 30 14:16

...a male view point again...buy a pumpkin like the rest of us..they re less scarey ..quote...
Comment by anon on October 30 18:36

i think cheryl wore it best and she so dosen't need to go on a ankle diet she looks fabulous as she is. the dress looks well better belted and cheryls shoes are look so much better with this dress than emmas shoes. red and white don't really go. sorry emma
Comment by bronagh on October 30 19:17

Cheryl this. Cheryl that. Let's have a hand for the underdog for a change. And in any case, isn't it embarassing for a teenager to wear the same dress as you considering it's Versace?
Comment by Annoyed on October 30 22:19

I think they both look bell-like. Just pick them up and ring them! LOL
Comment by Alice on October 31 01:35

I think Emma wears it better - she looks quirky and cool whereas Cheryl looks like an overly coiffured Barbie doll and far too try hard.
Comment by Isie on October 31 15:57

Cheryl Cole does have chunky ankles, you are blind if you don't see it!!
Comment by AC on November 01 12:42

Who'd want to look like a cheap plastic lamp-shade anyway...
Comment by cathy on November 01 15:26

Horrible unflattering dress, combined with shiny fake tan legs...yuk. Doesn't look any better with white legs either. Sack the stylist!
Comment by Steph on November 02 11:42

The dress is wearing Emma, where as Chezza is wearing the dress. The belt is the making of this scalloped number!
Comment by Pearl on November 02 16:56

Emma looks much better, I think the belt looks awful.
Comment by G on November 04 18:04

dress is vile but Emma looks best
Comment by RR on November 07 18:45

I personally hate this dress, do not think it could flatter anybody!
Comment by Rosemarie on March 16 23:16